Skip to main content

India's nationalist agenda is detrimental!

I usually do not give my personal opinion on this forum especially when these issues are not related to the Slavic or East European Studies. However, I was baffled by the very instance of artificial nationalism that a State can sponsor. During my childhood in our Mumbai school, we were misinformed all the time by our teachers about the Kashmir problem. India's textbooks were the prime-example about how the Mahatma Gandhi and Nehru were so peaceful that we were told to call the Mahatma Gandhi (and by no means, I am minimizing is impact or political contributions to various causes including the non-violence and the Independence movment) as the Rashtrapita or the Father of the Nation. My poor Catholic neighbors could have been equally confused as they could not understand how there can be two fathers? One the Holy Father and the other Father of the Nation. I mean in a cynical tone Bapuji was famous for testing his celibacy by sleeping with women in his bed. The Nehru dynasty that has ruled India since early days of Indian Independence and Jawarhlal the Head of the clan was referred to as Chacha-ji. I mean an uncle. When I used to look at my imaginary uncle's face, there he was staring down upon me the father of Indira Gandhi.

Indian nationalism while serving the needs of the few and imagination of many has continued to further alienate the national minorities. It is funny to see that now the Indian's are forced to stand up at each screening of the Bollywood movie to their funky national anthem called Jana Gana Mana...I remember how we were used to gather to sing it in our schools along with my Muslim friends. I could not fathom the expressions on their faces as we sang it proudly. We were told that we were the best and that we were building a just society. Now many years later the myths of just society have been continuing to resonate in my adapted "American Psyche."

It is like saying India was a great nation. The key verb is "was." And I looked up to Mount Kailash to see if Shiva is in his hiding with his serpent and his ox. But I could not find him. I looked for the just society but then I found myself having nightmares about Godhra, Kashmir, Indian farmers committing suicides, the caste based quotas and now the national anthem fiasco. Do we really need to stand up to respect something? Or respect remains in our hearts and minds? Do we need to fall on the feet of bhondu gurus like Swami Ramdevs or New Sai babas....Do I need to say Bharat mata ki Jai (Hail to Mother India) to be an Indian?

India has always been present in my life despite my Slavic garb and I cannot escape naturally who I am. But I can choose not to stand up when they screen the Bollywood thrillers when the national anthem blares. It is like the peace disturbing arti during the Navratri along with the loud garba  commercial dance competitions, along with that shriel Azan that blares out of the speakers at 4 am in the morning calling the "other" Indians to come to pray. Did the prophet (pbuh as it is customary in Islam) sanction use of the speakers for Azan? or Did the Hindu gods of Lalbag in their Ganesha like appearances mandated that we must give them a bundle of 21 leaves of a specific lawn herb? I mean Ganesha could be in heaven collecting these herbs as he walks around the pedicured lawns of Los Angeles while the rest of the California struggles with the drought.

What does it mean to be an Indian or Russian or an American? Where is my home? Where is my destination?  And I am not even going to touch upon the de-monetisation circus that Modi and his administration are playing. Go to Dubai, Modi to see the Indian business and hawala thriving...Wake up and look at the demolition of Babri masjid and rape of innocent Muslims of Godhra. Just because you are a majority that does not give you a right to insult your national minorities. Well what can be expected of the society that had sutees, nautch girls and now the famous dance bars masking as brothels. How can we explain peaceful religious zeal along with the renaissance of a certain branch of Hinduism that wiped out the Buddhist and Jain thoughts? Can we use general ignorant terms like Hindu or Muslim extremism to denote the attack on Bombay or the bomb blasts that shook Mumbail.

Well, I will not stand at playing of your national anthems. I choose to be sitting down and appreciating the melody of imagination that envisions a particular version of India. It is not the India that I was living in. The India of Emergency is long dead and so are Chachaji, Indiraji and Rajivji. The life goes on and so my friends Happy Holidays. India will live on so will the world except when the global warming catches up eventually to our own moment of silence. I don't believe that forcing people to stand up to a national anthem is particularly patriotic. After all the Lord Jesus and his daddy gave us the free will. And to end this monologue, I invite you to watch the commercialization of faith including of that Ramdev baba and living in Saudi Arabia- Naik, Zakir. I will add his video he was excited to get the award from the Saudi monarch.Does he know about Saudi bombing of Yemeni civilians?

I refuse to bow up to any monarchs, for the American spirit (and I do not mean Blanton's) is quite anti monarchical and anti-clerical (and I do not mean the corrupt clerk's of the Mumbai high courts or municipalities). I am waiting now for the Fatwas and Flying Carpets....One should go and read Taha Hussein and his Fi al-shiir al jahili.

Here is the dancing guru...and I am waiting for my flying carpet.


Popular posts from this blog


Web-comics: Some Links by Liladhar R. Pendse (UC Berkeley)

This exhibit also takes in consideration comics that are born digital. The webcomics represent a unique opportunity for their creators to provide outreach to multiple audiences. Below are some suggested webcomics that can make this exhibition more interesting to our visitors.The list below was adapted for use from, and other sites. Some of these comics might be sensitive to their viewers. I would advise viewer’s discretion. This is not a comprehensive list but it provides a meaningful insight into the mysterious world of the webcomics.

Nedroid Fun Times” by Anthony Clark.“Hark! A Vagrant” by Kate Beaton.“Hooray for Teamwork” by Owl Turd.“The Paradox of Choice” by Cat and Girl.“Spelling” by the Perry Bible Fellowship.“Lyme Disease” by Joy Ang.“Super Foods” by übertool.“Surreal Strokes” by ChaosLife.“The Future of Elections” by Saturday Morning Breakfast Cereal.“Grrl Power”-A webcomic about superheroines.“A…

CFP: A Century of Movement: Russian Culture and Global Community Since 1917

A Century of Movement: Russian Culture and Global Community Since 1917
CFP Deadline: April 7, 2017
October 12-13, 2017
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
Keynote Speakers: Katerina Clark and Marina Frolova-Walker
Conference Organizers: Jamie Blake and Grace Kweon, in collaboration with Annegret Fauser 
The cultural products of the last century reflect change, opportunity, and uncertainty, and demonstrate active negotiations between personal identity and social awareness, nationalism and cosmopolitanism, artistic voice and security. This conference, in the centennial year of the Revolution, seeks to explore the transformations set in motion during and after the events of 1917 through an examination of cultural production and practices, located both within and without Russia.

We will explore first and foremost the issue of human migration, particularly the patterns and developments set in motion by the Revolution. In light of today’s desperate discu…

CFP: Accelerated development? Socio-political landslides, cultural ruptures and literary history in Eastern Europe (Ghent University, Ghent, September 29 – October 1, 2017)

CALL FOR PAPERS Accelerated development? Socio-political landslides, cultural ruptures and literary history in Eastern Europe Ghent University September 29 – October 1, 2017
In 1964 the Bulgarian-Belarusian-Russian scholar Georgii Gachev coined the term ‘uskorennoe razvitie’ or ‘accelerated development’ in his 1964 monograph Accelerated Development of Literature: On the Basis of the Bulgarian Literature of the First Half of the 19thCenturyThe term describes what happened to Bulgarian literature during Ottoman rule. Being a ‘young’ and ‘peripheral’ literature, having started to develop only recently at the time, Bulgarian literature ‘had to’ go through the whole evolution of European literature at a high pace in order to catch up with the latter. One of the side effects of this accelerated development was that characteristics of different style periods could even co-occur. Gachev’s thought-provoking idea has never really received a l…